{
 "name": "SASE solutions index",
 "edition": "2026-11-13",
 "read_dates": [
  "2026-11-12",
  "2026-11-13"
 ],
 "source": "https://bestsasesolutions.com/datasets/",
 "license": "CC BY 4.0",
 "cite": "Best SASE Solutions, SASE Backbone and PoP Ledger and SASE Packaging Ledger, edition 13 Nov 2026, https://bestsasesolutions.com/datasets/ (CC BY 4.0).",
 "description": "16 SASE solutions scored 0 to 10 on seven criteria with the reason and the weight; weighted totals rounded and unrounded.",
 "rows": [
  {
   "rank": 1,
   "joint": "no",
   "vendor": "Versa Networks",
   "total": "7.2",
   "total_unrounded": "7.150",
   "platform": 8,
   "platform_weight": 25,
   "platform_reason": "Versa documents one operating system, single-pass engine and one console for SD-WAN and SSE, and Network World confirms the profiles were unified in Concerto 13.1.1. Policy was split in earlier releases, the management plane has several components, and SDxCentral reports Gartner warned on non-adjacent features.",
   "network": 6,
   "network_weight": 20,
   "network_reason": "Versa states 100+ PoPs, a traffic-engineered backbone, an SLA with uptime and latency targets and a China pricing region. SDxCentral reports Gartner praised its PoP estate, with no count. Its gateway status page showed 111 of 111 gateways available on 13 Nov 2026.",
   "security": 8,
   "security_weight": 20,
   "security_reason": "Versa documents NGFW, SWG, CASB, ZTNA, DLP, IPS and RBI, and CyberRatings.org rated its SSE and ZTNA AAA, though the SSE test dates from 2024. CASB, DLP and RBI tests: none found on 13 Nov 2026. Black Lotus Labs (28 Oct 2026) records Volt Typhoon exploiting Versa Director in 2024.",
   "operations": 6,
   "operations_weight": 10,
   "operations_reason": "Versa documents DEM across SD-WAN and SSE, ZTP and partner-delivered managed services, including a carrier-hosted service from Tata Communications. A Versa channel director says partners can resell or run fully managed services. A deployment time: none found on 13 Nov 2026.",
   "ai": 8,
   "ai_weight": 10,
   "ai_reason": "Versa documents a GenAI firewall controlling access and uploads, and SiliconANGLE and Network World confirm the firewall and zero-trust MCP in production. A central MCP enforcement point is still coming, and Fierce Network on 22 May 2026 reports only Versa's claim of verified AI agent actions.",
   "commercial": 6,
   "commercial_weight": 10,
   "commercial_reason": "Versa publishes an SLA with credits, and Network World and Megaport describe per-user or capacity licensing, with a third-party contract median. No current public price exists; the price book is a 2023 internal partner document.",
   "proof": 7,
   "proof_weight": 5,
   "proof_reason": "Versa names customers, press and a reseller confirm Swisscom and DISA deployments, and SDxCentral reports it in the Challengers box of the 2026 Gartner SASE Magic Quadrant on 3 Aug 2026. It is not a Leader and the customer count is vague.",
   "read": "2026-11-12"
  },
  {
   "rank": 2,
   "joint": "no",
   "vendor": "Cato Networks",
   "total": "6.5",
   "total_unrounded": "6.500",
   "platform": 6,
   "platform_weight": 25,
   "platform_reason": "Cato states an organically built platform running NGFW, threat prevention, CASB, DLP and ZTNA with one policy. AI security was partly acquired, edge devices are required, the endpoint client is new and Gartner flagged the modular adoption model; no independent source confirms the single platform.",
   "network": 7,
   "network_weight": 20,
   "network_reason": "Cato states 100+ PoPs on a private backbone, and its status page lists 104 PoP rows. Network World (3 Aug 2026) gives 85+ PoPs, from a vendor-briefed article. SLA terms: none found on 13 Nov 2026, and a PoP carrier degradation was open on 13 Nov 2026.",
   "security": 6,
   "security_weight": 20,
   "security_reason": "Cato documents SWG, CASB, RBI, ZTNA and sandboxing. DLP needs a separate license, and CyberRatings.org reports Cato refused to take part in its 2025 SSE test. OpenCVE lists 2026 Cato SDP Client CVEs, including a Windows privilege escalation (CVSS 8.5, fixed in 6.12.6).",
   "operations": 7,
   "operations_weight": 10,
   "operations_reason": "Cato documents one console, native DEM, managed NOC services and MSP licensing, and Channel Dive reports the SMB FlexPool for MSPs (2 Sep 2026). VentureBeat reports Swissport sites online in hours. Cato's status page shows two management application incidents in November 2026.",
   "ai": 8,
   "ai_weight": 10,
   "ai_reason": "Cato documents shadow AI discovery, prompt inspection and DLP in the same platform, and Fierce Network on 27 Oct 2026 restates the AI Endpoint launch, a report rather than a test. It needs CASB and premium licenses, and OpenTools says agent blocking covers only supported agents.",
   "commercial": 5,
   "commercial_weight": 10,
   "commercial_reason": "Cato documents its license catalog and models, and SDxCentral repeats user-based and site-bandwidth pricing. A price sheet and SLA document: none found on 13 Nov 2026. GBHackers lists a per-site or user quote with no price, and many capabilities are separate licenses.",
   "proof": 8,
   "proof_weight": 5,
   "proof_reason": "Cato states 5,200+ customers, while CTech reports 4,000+ and Ynetnews 4,800+, and SDxCentral cites a Gartner estimate of about 2,500. SDxCentral reports a Gartner SASE Leader placement and Forrester strong performer. VentureBeat names Swissport, and Cato is not yet profitable.",
   "read": "2026-11-12"
  },
  {
   "rank": 3,
   "joint": "no",
   "vendor": "Aryaka",
   "total": "6.4",
   "total_unrounded": "6.400",
   "platform": 6,
   "platform_weight": 25,
   "platform_reason": "Aryaka documents one single-pass platform for WAN and security. Third-party firewall runs as a separate managed service, clientless ZTNA is not fully available and third-party security can remain alongside the platform.",
   "network": 8,
   "network_weight": 20,
   "network_reason": "Aryaka runs its own private backbone with China PoPs, a 99.999 percent SLA with loss terms and a last-mile service; Wikipedia and CRN confirm the vendor-built network. PoP lists differ between pages and credits are capped.",
   "security": 6,
   "security_weight": 20,
   "security_reason": "Aryaka lists NGFW, SWG, IPS, CASB, DLP and ZTNA in one pass, and CRN confirms ZTNA joined the platform. OpenCVE shows no Aryaka entries on 13 Nov 2026. RBI and a lab test: none found on 13 Nov 2026; DLP shipped later than announced, and CyberSecurityNews ranks it ninth of ten without a test.",
   "operations": 6,
   "operations_weight": 10,
   "operations_reason": "Aryaka documents one portal, managed and co-managed options and most customers live in under 4 months; CRN and a reseller confirm the managed models. A named digital experience monitoring product is not found in the pages read on 12 Nov 2026.",
   "ai": 6,
   "ai_weight": 10,
   "ai_reason": "Aryaka documents GenAI discovery and prompt and upload controls, and CRN reports centralized policy. Channel Dive on 13 Nov 2025 reports the vendor's announcement without testing the feature. The capability is an add-on and was scheduled after it was announced.",
   "commercial": 6,
   "commercial_weight": 10,
   "commercial_reason": "Aryaka publishes three tiers, consumption billing and an SLA with credits, and CRN confirms per-site and user charging. No price is published and add-ons are separate. Channel Dive reports over 80 percent of revenue comes through the channel, and GBHackers lists a per-site or bandwidth quote.",
   "proof": 6,
   "proof_weight": 5,
   "proof_reason": "Aryaka states 500+ customers, and Channel Dive repeats that count and reports 60+ customers on Unified SASE. A Gartner placement: none found on 13 Nov 2026. Aryaka says it earned 17 G2 badges in Fall 2026, which is its own report, not an analyst placement.",
   "read": "2026-11-12"
  },
  {
   "rank": 4,
   "joint": "yes",
   "vendor": "iboss",
   "total": "6.3",
   "total_unrounded": "6.300",
   "platform": 8,
   "platform_weight": 25,
   "platform_reason": "iboss documents one console, one policy engine and its own SD-WAN appliances on the same platform, and PeerSpot reviewers confirm the single console. Several capabilities are add-ons outside the base tiers.",
   "network": 5,
   "network_weight": 20,
   "network_reason": "iboss states 100+ PoPs including mainland China and an SLA with availability and latency terms. Only 57 core sites are named, no private backbone or managed last mile is described and reviewers flag geographic latency.",
   "security": 6,
   "security_weight": 20,
   "security_reason": "iboss documents TLS decryption, sandboxing, DLP, CASB, RBI and ZTNA, and a CyberSecurityNews roundup table lists full TLS inspection and DLP, a listing rather than a test. The only test is vendor-commissioned. OpenCVE lists one 2024 medium XSS flaw (CVSS 4.3) and no 2026 entry.",
   "operations": 6,
   "operations_weight": 10,
   "operations_reason": "iboss documents auto-registering appliances, DEM and partner routes, and states in a 12 Nov 2026 release that its MSSP console switches between client tenants. DEM is a paid add-on, reviewers report deployments taking weeks, and 24x7 support is in a higher package.",
   "ai": 6,
   "ai_weight": 10,
   "ai_reason": "iboss documents inline AI policy, chat recording and DLP on AI uploads. Unite.AI on 3 Nov 2026 repeats iboss's AI DLP announcement, a report of the claim, not a test: a private preview is planned for December 2026. AI Security is an add-on.",
   "commercial": 6,
   "commercial_weight": 10,
   "commercial_reason": "iboss publishes three tiers, per-user pricing and an SLA credit table, and PeerSpot reviewers call pricing transparent. No dollar amount is published, so buyers must request a quote to compare cost.",
   "proof": 6,
   "proof_weight": 5,
   "proof_reason": "iboss states 4,000+ organizations and says GigaOm named it a Leader in its CASB Radar. Carahsoft lists case summaries with vendor-supplied figures, and CyberSecurityNews ranks it tenth of ten SWG vendors (14 Aug 2026). Forrester rated it a contender.",
   "read": "2026-11-12"
  },
  {
   "rank": 4,
   "joint": "yes",
   "vendor": "Netskope One",
   "total": "6.3",
   "total_unrounded": "6.300",
   "platform": 6,
   "platform_weight": 25,
   "platform_reason": "Netskope states one policy management point and a shared control plane for SD-WAN and SSE. SD-WAN was added to an SSE-first offering, branches need a gateway and part of data security was acquired.",
   "network": 7,
   "network_weight": 20,
   "network_reason": "Netskope states an owned private cloud of 120+ data centers including mainland China, and SDxCentral reports Gartner praised its PoP infrastructure strategy on 3 Aug 2026. The IPO filing as reported confirms the count. Only a latency SLA term was found and peering figures differ by page.",
   "security": 6,
   "security_weight": 20,
   "security_reason": "Netskope lists SWG, CASB, ZTNA, FWaaS, RBI, IPS and DLP with single-pass inspection. IPS and DNS security are firewall add-ons, and an SSE test: none found on 13 Nov 2026. OpenCVE lists 24 CVEs, including an 8.7 High Endpoint DLP driver overflow, none in KEV.",
   "operations": 8,
   "operations_weight": 10,
   "operations_reason": "Netskope documents digital experience monitoring and zero-touch onboarding in minutes, and CRN reports a partner provisioning MSP tenants in under 15 minutes. A reviewer reports configuration needs strong product knowledge.",
   "ai": 7,
   "ai_weight": 10,
   "ai_reason": "Netskope documents inline LLM and MCP inspection under one console and policy engine, and SiliconANGLE reports customer wins for its AI guardrails and gateway. The independent source confirms adoption, not how the controls work.",
   "commercial": 3,
   "commercial_weight": 10,
   "commercial_reason": "Netskope describes license levels and an analyst reports per-transaction pricing for one product. A price, tier table and SLA credit terms: none found on 13 Nov 2026. Virtualization Review reports Forrester saying pricing is on the higher end, and a CyberSecurityNews roundup lists per-user quote pricing.",
   "proof": 8,
   "proof_weight": 5,
   "proof_reason": "SiliconANGLE reports over 4,300 organizations from the IPO filing, and SDxCentral and Virtualization Review report Gartner and Forrester SASE Leader placements. Gartner gave a low financial score and an AI-focus caution, only one named case study was found, and Seeking Alpha reports a Morgan Stanley downgrade.",
   "read": "2026-11-12"
  },
  {
   "rank": 6,
   "joint": "yes",
   "vendor": "Fortinet FortiSASE",
   "total": "6.0",
   "total_unrounded": "5.950",
   "platform": 6,
   "platform_weight": 25,
   "platform_reason": "FortiSASE documents one operating system, one agent and one console across SSE and SD-WAN, and MSP Business repeats Fortinet's claim of an agentless small-site service. The SD-WAN hub path needs a separate bundle, and AIMultiple notes ZTNA requires FortiClient EMS, not an existing on-premises EMS.",
   "network": 5,
   "network_weight": 20,
   "network_reason": "FortiSASE states 190 to 200+ PoPs on owned infrastructure, a new Oman PoP and China through a partner. Nine legacy data centers retire on 15 Nov 2026 with forced migration, a subscription gets one to four PoPs unless more is bought, and the SLA is non-binding.",
   "security": 5,
   "security_weight": 20,
   "security_reason": "FortiSASE lists SWG, FWaaS, ZTNA, CASB, DLP and RBI, but a third-party test of FortiSASE: none found on 13 Nov 2026. Fortinet's 2026 record includes exploited critical flaws in FortiSandbox (CVSS 9.1) and FortiCloud SSO, a FortiClient remote code execution flaw and FortiGate compromises.",
   "operations": 8,
   "operations_weight": 10,
   "operations_reason": "FortiSASE documents a unified console, digital experience monitoring and an MSSP portal; PeerSpot, Network World and two managed providers confirm deployment times, unified management and managed options. A reviewer reports long implementation, and maintenance windows are vendor-set.",
   "ai": 6,
   "ai_weight": 10,
   "ai_reason": "FortiSASE documents real-time GenAI inspection with DLP and tenant restrictions in the same profile. Restrictions apply only to traffic FortiSASE sees, and guardrails are delivered as a separate service.",
   "commercial": 7,
   "commercial_weight": 10,
   "commercial_reason": "FortiSASE publishes tiers by user band and usage-based licensing, and a reseller lists per-user prices. Fortinet publishes no price, the SLA is non-binding, add-ons carry minimums, and MSP Business reports the 3 Nov 2026 FortiLink SASE Service gave no pricing or licensing terms.",
   "proof": 7,
   "proof_weight": 5,
   "proof_reason": "FortiSASE is a Gartner SASE Challenger, which SDxCentral confirms, and names customers, with an estimated 1,500 SASE customers. Yahoo Finance repeats Fortinet's Q3 2026 SASE billings growth of 31 percent, but it left the Leaders box and a FortiSASE customer count is not published.",
   "read": "2026-11-12"
  },
  {
   "rank": 6,
   "joint": "yes",
   "vendor": "Zscaler",
   "total": "6.0",
   "total_unrounded": "5.950",
   "platform": 5,
   "platform_weight": 25,
   "platform_reason": "Zscaler describes an integrated proxy platform with six core technologies. Branch SD-WAN is a separately priced appliance product, and SDxCentral reported in January 2024 that its offer used third-party SD-WAN before its own. Parts came by acquisition.",
   "network": 4,
   "network_weight": 20,
   "network_reason": "Zscaler states 160 to 200+ data centers, an SLA with availability and latency terms and China services. SDxCentral reports Gartner noted more connectivity issues than typical, and Zscaler's trust page lists 20 incidents from 16 Sep to 12 Nov 2026. No private backbone was found.",
   "security": 8,
   "security_weight": 20,
   "security_reason": "Zscaler documents SWG, CASB, DLP, cloud firewall with IPS, sandbox and isolation, and CyberRatings.org scored it 100 percent in its SSE and ZTNA tests. Advanced features are add-ons. OpenCVE lists 2026 Client Connector flaws (RCE and authentication bypass, CVSS 9.1) and a 9.6 SAML signature flaw.",
   "operations": 6,
   "operations_weight": 10,
   "operations_reason": "Zscaler documents ZTP, DEM tiers, AI-assisted administration and advisory services, and its Toll Group story claims new site setup fell from eight weeks to one weekend. Base DEM is narrow, and its trust page records an Admin UI incident on 12 Nov 2026.",
   "ai": 7,
   "ai_weight": 10,
   "ai_reason": "Zscaler documents GenAI policy with inline prompt visibility. Network World on 9 Jun 2026 reports Zscaler's announcement of AI Broker for MCP and A2A traffic and prompt extraction across 250+ GenAI apps, without a test. GenAI security sits in priced add-on modules.",
   "commercial": 6,
   "commercial_weight": 10,
   "commercial_reason": "Zscaler publishes bundles, sizing and SLA credit tiers, and SDxCentral reports Forrester credited its pricing progress while Gartner cautioned on value. No price is published, and Zscaler's data center map shows some data centers carry a surcharge with no dollar amounts.",
   "proof": 8,
   "proof_weight": 5,
   "proof_reason": "SDxCentral reports Zscaler third of three Leaders in the Q3 2025 Forrester SASE Wave, confirming the vendor-stated placement. ChannelLife repeats Zscaler's release on its 2026 Gartner SASE Leader placement, the first year. Customer figures, such as Toll Group's 250 sites, are vendor-stated.",
   "read": "2026-11-12"
  },
  {
   "rank": 8,
   "joint": "no",
   "vendor": "Palo Alto Networks Prisma SASE",
   "total": "5.5",
   "total_unrounded": "5.500",
   "platform": 4,
   "platform_weight": 25,
   "platform_reason": "Prisma SASE claims one pane of glass. It has two management options with different features, SD-WAN is a separate product linked by a thin client, and parts came by acquisition.",
   "network": 5,
   "network_weight": 20,
   "network_reason": "Prisma SASE states 100 to 150 locations, a China deployment and a 99.999 percent SLA figure, and SDxCentral quotes an analyst on a direct AT&T private path. The backbone runs on public clouds, and Forrester advised improving backbone controls and standardizing PoP services.",
   "security": 8,
   "security_weight": 20,
   "security_reason": "Prisma SASE lists ZTNA, SWG, CASB, RBI and FWaaS, and CyberRatings.org rated it Recommended in its SSE test. RBI and DLP are add-ons. The 29 Sep 2026 CyberRatings result covers VM-Series, a different product, and OpenCVE tags Prisma Access on several November 2026 PAN-OS CVEs.",
   "operations": 6,
   "operations_weight": 10,
   "operations_reason": "Prisma SASE documents a single console, deployment services and an AT&T managed service, and SDxCentral reports a ServiceNow marketplace app from 9 Dec 2025. Full DEM is an add-on, and a deployment time: none found on 13 Nov 2026.",
   "ai": 5,
   "ai_weight": 10,
   "ai_reason": "Prisma SASE classifies GenAI apps and applies access and upload controls in its existing architecture. The capability needs an add-on license, and no price or independent test of it was found in the pages read.",
   "commercial": 4,
   "commercial_weight": 10,
   "commercial_reason": "Prisma SASE publishes license meters, editions and add-ons, but no price was found and the SLA and pricing pages returned 404. SDxCentral reported on 9 Sep 2025 that Forrester cited high pricing and cost creep from growing licensing options.",
   "proof": 8,
   "proof_weight": 5,
   "proof_reason": "SiliconANGLE reports over 6,300 SASE customers, and SDxCentral reports Prisma SASE as a Forrester SASE Wave Leader (second of three) and a 2026 Gartner Leader. Gartner dropped it from first to third on execution, partly on reportedly expensive pricing, and cited limited customer need for the browser.",
   "read": "2026-11-12"
  },
  {
   "rank": 9,
   "joint": "no",
   "vendor": "Cloudflare One",
   "total": "5.4",
   "total_unrounded": "5.350",
   "platform": 5,
   "platform_weight": 25,
   "platform_reason": "Cloudflare One documents one control plane across its SASE components. Wikipedia dates the platform to October 2020 with two later acquisitions, Area 1 and Nefeli, and does not say how far they are merged. The WAN service is standalone, and DLP and RBI are add-ons.",
   "network": 5,
   "network_weight": 20,
   "network_reason": "Cloudflare One lists 330 to 348 cities including mainland China, all vendor figures, and China service is for web content. SLA terms for SASE: none found on 13 Nov 2026. Reported outages include a six-hour BGP withdrawal on 20 Feb 2026, a 62-minute outage in September and a degradation on 11 Nov 2026.",
   "security": 5,
   "security_weight": 20,
   "security_reason": "Cloudflare One documents SWG, multimode CASB, DLP, RBI and ZTNA. CyberRatings.org rated its SSE Caution with 2.95 percent security effectiveness. OpenCVE lists a 2022 WARP mobile client bypass of the Lock WARP switch on iOS (CVE-2022-3322), updated 17 Jun 2026.",
   "operations": 6,
   "operations_weight": 10,
   "operations_reason": "Cloudflare One documents one dashboard, DEM on all plans, rollout in hours and a 45-day customer migration. Channel Dive (22 Jun 2026) reports a partner design program with funding and blueprints. Support differs by tier, and The Register reported a dashboard loop that caused an API outage.",
   "ai": 6,
   "ai_weight": 10,
   "ai_reason": "Cloudflare One documents shadow AI visibility, block or isolate controls, MCP security and prompt DLP. AIMultiple (4 Nov 2026) says full DLP is an add-on and predefined profiles apply below the contract tier, so prompt DLP depends on that add-on.",
   "commercial": 6,
   "commercial_weight": 10,
   "commercial_reason": "Cloudflare One publishes a free plan and a $7 per user plan, with seat-based packaging. Contract pricing is unpublished and the SLA does not list Zero Trust services. AIMultiple says RBI is an add-on and log retention is 24 hours on Free.",
   "proof": 6,
   "proof_weight": 5,
   "proof_reason": "SDxCentral reports on 3 Aug 2026 Cloudflare One alone in the Gartner SASE Visionaries box, and Cloudflare says it is a Visionary in both Gartner quadrants. It is not a Leader, a product customer count: none found on 13 Nov 2026, and press reports outages and layoffs.",
   "read": "2026-11-12"
  },
  {
   "rank": 10,
   "joint": "no",
   "vendor": "Open Systems",
   "total": "5.1",
   "total_unrounded": "5.050",
   "platform": 6,
   "platform_weight": 25,
   "platform_reason": "Open Systems states SD-WAN and SSE are one platform with one policy and one portal. Parcel and Postal Technology International reported on 23 Sep 2024 the planned Swiss Post acquisition, repeating the parties' announcement. OT security is a partner product and two operating models are still rolling out.",
   "network": 6,
   "network_weight": 20,
   "network_reason": "Open Systems states a backbone of 500+ PoPs in 48 countries including China, availability SLAs and managed last-mile lines. The page does not name who operates the PoPs, and the only independent source is a 2011 ENX listing, which does not confirm the backbone.",
   "security": 4,
   "security_weight": 20,
   "security_reason": "Open Systems lists ZTNA, SWG, CASB, firewall, email security and sandbox. OpenCVE showed no CVE for the vendor on 13 Nov 2026, and the one entry under the open-systems slug is not attributed to the SASE product. DLP is coming soon, and RBI and a lab test: none found on 13 Nov 2026.",
   "operations": 5,
   "operations_weight": 10,
   "operations_reason": "Open Systems documents Level-3 support, an API and an MSP platform, and a Microsoft Marketplace card names it publisher of a managed secure SD-WAN service on Azure, in its own wording. DEM and Terraform are coming soon and several AI specialists are not live.",
   "ai": 4,
   "ai_weight": 10,
   "ai_reason": "Open Systems documents an AI policy category in the SWG and upload blocking. Prompt-level DLP is coming soon, so controls on what users type into AI tools are not yet available.",
   "commercial": 4,
   "commercial_weight": 10,
   "commercial_reason": "Open Systems states a user-based flat fee and three operating models with separate pricing. No price is published, and each model is quoted on its own.",
   "proof": 5,
   "proof_weight": 5,
   "proof_reason": "Open Systems names 14 customers and claims a Forrester Wave Leader placement for SASE services. IDC rated it Major Player. A Magic Quadrant placement and customer count: none found on 13 Nov 2026, and its In the News page shows no item dated 2026.",
   "read": "2026-11-12"
  },
  {
   "rank": 11,
   "joint": "no",
   "vendor": "Barracuda SecureEdge",
   "total": "4.9",
   "total_unrounded": "4.900",
   "platform": 5,
   "platform_weight": 25,
   "platform_reason": "Barracuda states one SASE platform configured from one cloud portal, and a PeerSpot reviewer reports consolidation. Components are ordered separately, branches need a site device, data protection is planned work and another reviewer wants more OT and ICS support.",
   "network": 4,
   "network_weight": 20,
   "network_reason": "Barracuda runs on Azure regions in Europe and a few other regions, with a 99.5 percent availability SLA and LTE backup. Microsoft runs the backbone, the SLA has no latency term and a China option is not found in the pages read on 12 Nov 2026.",
   "security": 5,
   "security_weight": 20,
   "security_reason": "Barracuda documents IPS, sandboxing, URL filtering, ZTNA, cloud app policy and DLP, with DLP in the top tier. RBI and a lab test: none found on 13 Nov 2026. A reviewer reports false negatives, and OpenCVE lists a 2023 appliance flaw, CVE-2023-26213 (CVSS 7.2).",
   "operations": 5,
   "operations_weight": 10,
   "operations_reason": "Barracuda documents zero-touch devices, dashboards and an MSP portal, and a PeerSpot reviewer reports easy setup with zero-touch configs. DEM and a deployment time: none found on 13 Nov 2026. Logs keep 30 days and one reviewer finds the GUI hard to use.",
   "ai": 6,
   "ai_weight": 10,
   "ai_reason": "Barracuda documents prompt inspection that blocks or logs GenAI content, and PeerSpot users describe prompt and upload blocking. SiliconANGLE reports Barracuda's claim of 1,300+ services covered from October 2026. Coverage is for supported services and aimed at smaller firms.",
   "commercial": 6,
   "commercial_weight": 10,
   "commercial_reason": "Barracuda publishes a $6.50 per user list price and a 99.5 percent SLA. SiliconANGLE reports Barracuda's statement that AI data security is included at no extra cost in Premium Access. Fair use limits apply, and a third-party price figure: none found on 13 Nov 2026.",
   "proof": 3,
   "proof_weight": 5,
   "proof_reason": "Microsoft lists Barracuda as a partner, its marketplace shows 257 ratings and PeerSpot ranks it 12th. A customer count and analyst placement: none found on 13 Nov 2026. CyberSecurityNews ranks it tenth of ten with no test result, and a 21 Oct 2026 Barracuda blog names a partner only.",
   "read": "2026-11-12"
  },
  {
   "rank": 12,
   "joint": "no",
   "vendor": "Cisco Secure Access and SD-WAN",
   "total": "4.5",
   "total_unrounded": "4.500",
   "platform": 3,
   "platform_weight": 25,
   "platform_reason": "Cisco sells SSE in one subscription and dashboard. SD-WAN is a separate product with its own management applications, the combined tool is not yet available in most regions, and Gartner Peer Insights lists the Meraki-based Secure Connect bundle separately as Legacy.",
   "network": 4,
   "network_weight": 20,
   "network_reason": "Cisco lists 96 regions and a 99.999 percent commercially reasonable efforts target, and SDxCentral reports Gartner credited its PoP infrastructure on 3 Aug 2026, with no count given. Part of the footprint is on AWS, no private backbone is described and China needs a separate operator.",
   "security": 5,
   "security_weight": 20,
   "security_reason": "Cisco lists ZTNA, SWG, CASB, FWaaS and DLP, and SE Labs awarded AAA for identity attacks only. RBI: none found on 13 Nov 2026. CyberRatings.org rated Cisco's virtual firewall Caution (66.10 percent) on 29 Sep 2026, and OpenCVE lists exploited SD-WAN Manager flaws, one at CVSS 9.8.",
   "operations": 5,
   "operations_weight": 10,
   "operations_reason": "Cisco documents a single Secure Access console, an integrated DEM module and carrier-managed options. Its status history lists 82 maintenance entries for October 2026. Full DEM needs a separate ThousandEyes license, a new-rollout deployment time: none found on 13 Nov 2026, and SD-WAN runs in other consoles.",
   "ai": 6,
   "ai_weight": 10,
   "ai_reason": "Cisco documents AI Access covering 720+ apps with guardrails in the same DLP policy, plus MCP inspection. Spiceworks on 30 Sep 2026 repeats Cisco's MCP discovery and policy claims without a test. Network World also lists it under a separate AI product family.",
   "commercial": 5,
   "commercial_weight": 10,
   "commercial_reason": "Cisco publishes package options and per-user or per-site licensing, but no price. The SLA text is on request and ordering terms need a login. ZeroTrustCost, a third-party reference, says Cisco Secure Access is sold through partner quotes and gives its own estimate.",
   "proof": 7,
   "proof_weight": 5,
   "proof_reason": "SDxCentral reports Cisco as a Challenger, not a Leader, in the 2026 Gartner SASE Magic Quadrant, marked down on patching and customer concerns, and cites about 500 SASE customers in 2025. Gartner Peer Insights shows 4.8 from 88 ratings, which is not a placement.",
   "read": "2026-11-12"
  },
  {
   "rank": 13,
   "joint": "no",
   "vendor": "Forcepoint",
   "total": "4.4",
   "total_unrounded": "4.400",
   "platform": 3,
   "platform_weight": 25,
   "platform_reason": "Forcepoint claims one console for its SSE technologies. The SSE stack was assembled through acquisitions, SD-WAN is managed in a separate console, the CEO's 2026 priorities in CRN omit SASE, and AIMultiple says agentless ZTNA covers only HTTP and HTTPS apps.",
   "network": 4,
   "network_weight": 20,
   "network_reason": "Forcepoint has an SLA with availability and latency terms and an SD-WAN test rating that a second CyberRatings.org page also lists, dated 2024. PoPs are built on AWS with no private backbone, PoP counts are from 2022 and 2023, and China: none found on 13 Nov 2026.",
   "security": 6,
   "security_weight": 20,
   "security_reason": "Forcepoint documents inline DLP, CASB and SWG with RBI and CDR. A third-party SSE or ZTNA test: none found on 13 Nov 2026 on CyberRatings.org. Full RBI is an add-on, and NVD lists a High NGFW policy bypass (CVSS 7.9) and a Medium endpoint DLP flaw.",
   "operations": 4,
   "operations_weight": 10,
   "operations_reason": "Forcepoint has an MSSP portal and ZTP confirmed in an independent SD-WAN test. SD-WAN uses a separate console, and end-user digital experience monitoring and a deployment time are not found in the pages read on 12 Nov 2026.",
   "ai": 5,
   "ai_weight": 10,
   "ai_reason": "Forcepoint documents inline shadow AI control, CASB upload controls and API connectors for Bedrock, Copilot, ChatGPT Enterprise and Claude. Some coverage is API-based, and a shattered.io comparison reports Forcepoint's October 2026 AI DLP claim with no measurement behind it.",
   "commercial": 5,
   "commercial_weight": 10,
   "commercial_reason": "Forcepoint sells annual per-user editions and publishes an SLA, but no price. CSO Online puts Forcepoint ONE CASB at $120 per user per year on AWS Marketplace, a journalist's estimate. Over 95 percent of sales go through partners, and outlets call pricing opaque.",
   "proof": 5,
   "proof_weight": 5,
   "proof_reason": "Forcepoint states 12K+ customers and a Forrester SSE Leader placement, and AWS Marketplace shows 4.2 from 113 reviews for Forcepoint ONE. Gartner placed it Visionary, the confirmed analyst placements are for DLP rather than SASE, and the company was split in 2023.",
   "read": "2026-11-12"
  },
  {
   "rank": 14,
   "joint": "yes",
   "vendor": "Check Point SASE",
   "total": "4.1",
   "total_unrounded": "4.100",
   "platform": 4,
   "platform_weight": 25,
   "platform_reason": "Check Point claims one cloud dashboard and a unified SaaS view. The SASE service came from the Perimeter 81 acquisition, which Wikipedia lists with no SD-WAN. An executive said it needed about two years of retooling, and SaaS security uses a separate portal.",
   "network": 4,
   "network_weight": 20,
   "network_reason": "Check Point claims a private backbone with 80 to 90 locations and a licensed Shanghai PoP. Counts differ by page, some locations are run by cloud providers, an SLA: none found on 13 Nov 2026, and its status page records a 25 Aug 2026 Israel-1 incident after an ISP loss.",
   "security": 5,
   "security_weight": 20,
   "security_reason": "Check Point lists web filtering, threat prevention, CASB, DLP and ZTNA. DLP covers only browser traffic, malware scanning is limited, and a SASE lab test: none found on 13 Nov 2026. NVD still shows two Harmony SASE client CVEs, the later published 14 Jan 2026.",
   "operations": 4,
   "operations_weight": 10,
   "operations_reason": "Check Point documents a unified console, zero-touch SD-WAN and MSP bundles. A deployment time and DEM: none found on 13 Nov 2026. Its status page records a 6 Jul 2026 Zero Trust outage of about 2 hours, and G2 Learn Hub says setup is not always simple.",
   "ai": 5,
   "ai_weight": 10,
   "ai_reason": "Check Point documents GenAI discovery, prompt DLP and tenant restrictions, and G2 Learn Hub reports an 88 percent G2 review score for its DLP configuration, which is a review score, not a test. The SASE overview describes monitoring only, without blocking.",
   "commercial": 2,
   "commercial_weight": 10,
   "commercial_reason": "Check Point documents a PAYG license for MSSP tenants. G2 Learn Hub lists the starting price as on request and says reviewers note it is not cheap. A price, tier table and SLA: none found on 13 Nov 2026, and China needs a dedicated license.",
   "proof": 4,
   "proof_weight": 5,
   "proof_reason": "Check Point states 12,000+ customers and names a few, and Yahoo Finance relays an executive's claim of tens of thousands, which shows only that it was made. A SASE placement: none found on 13 Nov 2026, the Q3 2026 results omit SASE and a buyer guide notes fewer case studies.",
   "read": "2026-11-12"
  },
  {
   "rank": 14,
   "joint": "yes",
   "vendor": "HPE Aruba Networking SASE",
   "total": "4.1",
   "total_unrounded": "4.050",
   "platform": 4,
   "platform_weight": 25,
   "platform_reason": "HPE Aruba configures SD-WAN and SSE from one orchestrator, and DataCenterNews repeats HPE's single-interface claim without testing it. Policy objects are still separate, and a partner engineer quoted by CRN called EdgeConnect only somewhat integrated in Aruba Central, due in the first half of 2027.",
   "network": 3,
   "network_weight": 20,
   "network_reason": "HPE Aruba lists about 37 SSE PoPs and hybrid WAN transports. PoPs are hosted on public clouds, a vendor-run backbone, an SLA and a mainland China location are not found in the pages read on 12 Nov 2026.",
   "security": 4,
   "security_weight": 20,
   "security_reason": "HPE Aruba lists SWG, CASB, DLP, ZTNA and FWaaS, with DLP as a file security profile. RBI and an SSE test: none found on 13 Nov 2026. Cyber Press reports 40 SD-WAN flaws fixed in September 2026, including unauthenticated bypasses rated CVSS 9.8 and 9.9.",
   "operations": 5,
   "operations_weight": 10,
   "operations_reason": "HPE Aruba documents DEM and shared troubleshooting, and its vendor-run status page showed SSE operational on 13 Nov 2026. Cyber Press reports September 2026 EdgeConnect denial-of-service flaws where some cases need manual recovery, and consoles are still in transition into 2027.",
   "ai": 5,
   "ai_weight": 10,
   "ai_reason": "HPE Aruba documents DLP on GenAI prompts and CASB policy for GenAI apps. Only these two vendor statements were found, with no independent confirmation or detail on enforcement.",
   "commercial": 4,
   "commercial_weight": 10,
   "commercial_reason": "HPE Aruba lists SD-WAN tiers and a starting software price, while SSE is request-a-quote with no stated price unit. SLA terms: none found on 13 Nov 2026. SDxCentral reports a Gartner note on too many pricing options, which concerns the campus LAN line.",
   "proof": 5,
   "proof_weight": 5,
   "proof_reason": "HPE Aruba names customers and claims an SD-WAN Leader placement. Placements are vendor-hosted, a customer count is not found in the pages read on 12 Nov 2026, and ETR shows a low security net score.",
   "read": "2026-11-12"
  },
  {
   "rank": 16,
   "joint": "no",
   "vendor": "VeloCloud by Arista",
   "total": "2.2",
   "total_unrounded": "2.150",
   "platform": 2,
   "platform_weight": 25,
   "platform_reason": "VeloCloud offers a branch platform with a single pane for SD-WAN. The SSE layer comes from partners, analysts say VeloCloud can no longer claim single-vendor SASE, and Network World, relaying Arista, says its July 2026 security application has its own management console.",
   "network": 3,
   "network_weight": 20,
   "network_reason": "VeloCloud has gateways hosted by itself or partners and multi-link steering. The PoP count includes partners, PoPs run on public cloud, and an SLA and a China option are not found in the pages read on 12 Nov 2026.",
   "security": 1,
   "security_weight": 20,
   "security_reason": "VeloCloud documents a branch firewall with IDS/IPS, URL and DNS filtering, and Network World repeats Arista's claim without a test. A cloud SWG, CASB, DLP, RBI or ZTNA: none found on 13 Nov 2026. The Hacker News reports three exploited orchestrator flaws, up to CVSS 10, since July 2026.",
   "operations": 4,
   "operations_weight": 10,
   "operations_reason": "VeloCloud documents a central orchestrator with ZTP, and partners deliver managed services. DEM and a vendor deployment time: none found on 13 Nov 2026. Network World reports the September 2026 orchestrator flaw also hit hosted deployments, some on-prem fixes were pending, and Arista warned of batched security releases.",
   "ai": 0,
   "ai_weight": 10,
   "ai_reason": "VeloCloud mentions GenAI only as traffic to optimize. Visibility or data control for GenAI is not found in the pages read on 12 Nov 2026.",
   "commercial": 2,
   "commercial_weight": 10,
   "commercial_reason": "VeloCloud sells three subscription editions, and SDxCentral reports Arista saying partners can port licenses within a geography. A price and SLA: none found on 13 Nov 2026. Network World, repeating Arista, says branch security is a paid upgrade, and a court dispute and analyst report describe price increases.",
   "proof": 5,
   "proof_weight": 5,
   "proof_reason": "SDxCentral and Dell'Oro report about 20,000 customers, while SDxCentral cites William Blair at above 18,000, and a partner repeats SD-WAN Leader recognition. Analysts report slowing momentum and share loss, and William Blair says Arista must rebuild channel trust that frayed under Broadcom.",
   "read": "2026-11-12"
  }
 ]
}