Criterion, read 12/13 Nov 2026
Security depth measures which security functions are documented, and what independent tests exist
See the indexAll seven criteria
SWG, CASB, DLP, ZTNA, FWaaS, RBI and threat prevention as documented, and independent test results where they exist.
The branch firewall and the VPN concentrator inspected traffic and controlled access. The replacement has to cover SWG, CASB, DLP, ZTNA, FWaaS, RBI and threat prevention as the vendor documents them. Zscaler documents a cloud firewall with TLS/SSL inspection and cloud IPS, and Cisco states a full-proxy SWG with TLS decryption and file sandboxing. Cato states that its malware prevention applies AI-driven prevention and sandboxing, including to files inside TLS.
Independent tests cover some vendors only. CyberRatings.org's July 2025 SSE test rated Fortinet, Palo Alto Networks, Versa and Zscaler Recommended and Cisco, Cloudflare and Skyhigh Caution, and the lab said it could not test Cato or Netskope. SE Labs tested Cisco Universal ZTNA against 30 identity-based attack scenarios in July 2025, and the test did not cover the SWG, CASB, DLP or FWaaS. Versa states results from CyberRatings.org for its Cloud NGFW, which ran on an AWS instance. A third-party lab result for Cato was not found on 12 Nov 2026. iboss cites a Miercom test that iboss commissioned.
| Index rank | Vendor | Score | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Versa Networks | 8 | Versa documents NGFW, SWG, CASB, ZTNA, DLP, IPS and RBI, and CyberRatings.org rated its SSE and ZTNA AAA, though the SSE test dates from 2024. CASB, DLP and RBI tests: none found on 13 Nov 2026. Black Lotus Labs (28 Oct 2026) records Volt Typhoon exploiting Versa Director in 2024. |
| 2 | Cato Networks | 6 | Cato documents SWG, CASB, RBI, ZTNA and sandboxing. DLP needs a separate license, and CyberRatings.org reports Cato refused to take part in its 2025 SSE test. OpenCVE lists 2026 Cato SDP Client CVEs, including a Windows privilege escalation (CVSS 8.5, fixed in 6.12.6). |
| 3 | Aryaka | 6 | Aryaka lists NGFW, SWG, IPS, CASB, DLP and ZTNA in one pass, and CRN confirms ZTNA joined the platform. OpenCVE shows no Aryaka entries on 13 Nov 2026. RBI and a lab test: none found on 13 Nov 2026; DLP shipped later than announced, and CyberSecurityNews ranks it ninth of ten without a test. |
| 4= | iboss | 6 | iboss documents TLS decryption, sandboxing, DLP, CASB, RBI and ZTNA, and a CyberSecurityNews roundup table lists full TLS inspection and DLP, a listing rather than a test. The only test is vendor-commissioned. OpenCVE lists one 2024 medium XSS flaw (CVSS 4.3) and no 2026 entry. |
| 4= | Netskope One | 6 | Netskope lists SWG, CASB, ZTNA, FWaaS, RBI, IPS and DLP with single-pass inspection. IPS and DNS security are firewall add-ons, and an SSE test: none found on 13 Nov 2026. OpenCVE lists 24 CVEs, including an 8.7 High Endpoint DLP driver overflow, none in KEV. |
| 6= | Fortinet FortiSASE | 5 | FortiSASE lists SWG, FWaaS, ZTNA, CASB, DLP and RBI, but a third-party test of FortiSASE: none found on 13 Nov 2026. Fortinet's 2026 record includes exploited critical flaws in FortiSandbox (CVSS 9.1) and FortiCloud SSO, a FortiClient remote code execution flaw and FortiGate compromises. |
| 6= | Zscaler | 8 | Zscaler documents SWG, CASB, DLP, cloud firewall with IPS, sandbox and isolation, and CyberRatings.org scored it 100 percent in its SSE and ZTNA tests. Advanced features are add-ons. OpenCVE lists 2026 Client Connector flaws (RCE and authentication bypass, CVSS 9.1) and a 9.6 SAML signature flaw. |
| 8 | Palo Alto Networks Prisma SASE | 8 | Prisma SASE lists ZTNA, SWG, CASB, RBI and FWaaS, and CyberRatings.org rated it Recommended in its SSE test. RBI and DLP are add-ons. The 29 Sep 2026 CyberRatings result covers VM-Series, a different product, and OpenCVE tags Prisma Access on several November 2026 PAN-OS CVEs. |
| 9 | Cloudflare One | 5 | Cloudflare One documents SWG, multimode CASB, DLP, RBI and ZTNA. CyberRatings.org rated its SSE Caution with 2.95 percent security effectiveness. OpenCVE lists a 2022 WARP mobile client bypass of the Lock WARP switch on iOS (CVE-2022-3322), updated 17 Jun 2026. |
| 10 | Open Systems | 4 | Open Systems lists ZTNA, SWG, CASB, firewall, email security and sandbox. OpenCVE showed no CVE for the vendor on 13 Nov 2026, and the one entry under the open-systems slug is not attributed to the SASE product. DLP is coming soon, and RBI and a lab test: none found on 13 Nov 2026. |
| 11 | Barracuda SecureEdge | 5 | Barracuda documents IPS, sandboxing, URL filtering, ZTNA, cloud app policy and DLP, with DLP in the top tier. RBI and a lab test: none found on 13 Nov 2026. A reviewer reports false negatives, and OpenCVE lists a 2023 appliance flaw, CVE-2023-26213 (CVSS 7.2). |
| 12 | Cisco Secure Access and SD-WAN | 5 | Cisco lists ZTNA, SWG, CASB, FWaaS and DLP, and SE Labs awarded AAA for identity attacks only. RBI: none found on 13 Nov 2026. CyberRatings.org rated Cisco's virtual firewall Caution (66.10 percent) on 29 Sep 2026, and OpenCVE lists exploited SD-WAN Manager flaws, one at CVSS 9.8. |
| 13 | Forcepoint | 6 | Forcepoint documents inline DLP, CASB and SWG with RBI and CDR. A third-party SSE or ZTNA test: none found on 13 Nov 2026 on CyberRatings.org. Full RBI is an add-on, and NVD lists a High NGFW policy bypass (CVSS 7.9) and a Medium endpoint DLP flaw. |
| 14= | Check Point SASE | 5 | Check Point lists web filtering, threat prevention, CASB, DLP and ZTNA. DLP covers only browser traffic, malware scanning is limited, and a SASE lab test: none found on 13 Nov 2026. NVD still shows two Harmony SASE client CVEs, the later published 14 Jan 2026. |
| 14= | HPE Aruba Networking SASE | 4 | HPE Aruba lists SWG, CASB, DLP, ZTNA and FWaaS, with DLP as a file security profile. RBI and an SSE test: none found on 13 Nov 2026. Cyber Press reports 40 SD-WAN flaws fixed in September 2026, including unauthenticated bypasses rated CVSS 9.8 and 9.9. |
| 16 | VeloCloud by Arista | 1 | VeloCloud documents a branch firewall with IDS/IPS, URL and DNS filtering, and Network World repeats Arista's claim without a test. A cloud SWG, CASB, DLP, RBI or ZTNA: none found on 13 Nov 2026. The Hacker News reports three exploited orchestrator flaws, up to CVSS 10, since July 2026. |
Where Cato is behind
Cato publishes no price or SLA credit terms, and while an existing firewall or SD-WAN can connect to Cato over IPsec, the full single-platform model has Cato Sockets replace the branch firewall and SD-WAN edge.
Sources
- lumen.com/blog/en-us/silent-train-volt-typhoon-operational-framework, read 13 Nov 2026
- app.opencve.io/cve, read 13 Nov 2026
- aryaka.com/blog/critical-php-vulnerabilities-aryaka-protection, read 13 Nov 2026
- app.opencve.io/cve, read 13 Nov 2026
- app.opencve.io/cve, read 13 Nov 2026
- theregister.com/security/2026/10/07/fortibleed-still-a-bleeding-nuisance-as-fbi-, read 13 Nov 2026
- app.opencve.io/cve, read 13 Nov 2026
- finance.yahoo.com/technology/ai/articles/cyberratings-org-nss-labs-announce-1000, read 13 Nov 2026
Last reviewed 13 Nov 2026.